ROMANTIC CRITICISM (1798-1832)

HISTORICAL CONTEXT

AspectDetails
Period1798 (Lyrical Ballads) to 1832 (death of Scott, Reform Act)
Peak: 1789-1824
Reaction AgainstNeoclassicism: Rules, reason, restraint, imitation, polish
Industrial Revolution: Mechanization, urbanization, materialism
Core ValuesImagination over Reason
Emotion/Feeling over Intellect
Nature as source of inspiration
Individualism over Universal truths
Spontaneity over Artifice
Originality over Imitation
Freedom over Rules
Revolution ContextFrench Revolution (1789) - hope, then disillusionment
Political & social upheaval
Emphasis on individual liberty
MCQ AlertRomanticism = Imagination + Emotion + Nature + Freedom (NOT rules, reason, imitation)

WILLIAM WORDSWORTH (1770-1850)

Preface to Lyrical Ballads (1800, revised 1802)

AspectDetails
Publication1798: Lyrical Ballads (Wordsworth & Coleridge) published anonymously
1800: Second edition with Preface by Wordsworth
1802: Revised Preface (expanded, added discussion of "What is a Poet?")
Significance: Manifesto of English Romanticism
PurposeExplain and defend new poetic experiment
Break from 18th-century poetic diction and subjects
MCQ KeyPreface to Lyrical Ballads (1800/1802) = Manifesto of English Romanticism

Wordsworth's Theory of Poetry

ConceptDetails
Famous Definition"Poetry is the spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings: it takes its origin from emotion recollected in tranquillity"
Two stages:
1. Spontaneous overflow (immediate emotion)
2. Recollection in tranquillity (reflection, artistic shaping)
Process1. Poet experiences emotion
2. Emotion subsides
3. Poet recalls emotion in calm state
4. Similar emotion arises in recollection
5. This becomes poetry
Balance: Spontaneity (emotion) + Contemplation (thought)
Subject Matter"Common incidents of life" - ordinary people, situations
NOT: Classical mythology, aristocratic life
YES: Rural life, peasants, children, nature, simple folk
"Low and rustic life" chosen because:
• Men speak plainer language
• Elementary feelings exist in purer form
• Passions incorporated with beautiful forms of nature
Language"Real language of men" - NOT artificial poetic diction
Rejection: 18th-century "gaudy and inane phraseology"
Selection: Language really used by men (especially rural men)
Purified: Remove defects, retain naturalness
NO difference in language of prose and poetry (controversial claim)
Famous Quote"Spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings" + "emotion recollected in tranquillity"

What is a Poet? (1802 Addition)

QuestionWordsworth's Answer
Nature of Poet"A man speaking to men" - NOT superior being, but representative human
More sensitive, enthusiastic, tender
Greater knowledge of human nature
More comprehensive soul
Poet's Qualities• Greater sensibility (feels more deeply)
• Greater power of expression
• More enthusiasm and tenderness
• Thinks and feels in "spirit of human passions"
• Delights in own passions and volitions
• Rejoices in spirit of life everywhere
Poet's FunctionGive immediate pleasure
Convey passion through metrical language
Interpreter of nature and humanity
Bind together "vast empire of human society"
DistinctionPoet differs in degree, not kind from other men
More alive to sensation, more passionate
Key Phrase"A man speaking to men" - poet as representative human, NOT superior being

Purpose of Poetry

ConceptDetails
Primary PurposeGive PLEASURE - immediate, not didactic
"We have no sympathy but what is propagated by pleasure"
Truth Through PleasurePoetry conveys truth, but through pleasure
Pleasure = means AND end
NOT like medicine (disguised instruction)
Moral EffectImplicit, not explicit
Refines feelings, enlarges sympathies
Makes readers more humane

Meter and Verse

IssueWordsworth's Position
Why Use Meter?Meter adds pleasure
Creates "musical" quality
Regulates emotion (prevents too much pain in painful subjects)
Tempering effect on realistic subjects
Prose vs. PoetryControversial claim: NO essential difference in language
Main difference = meter/rhythm
Critics objected: poetry requires heightened language

Wordsworth's Significance

AchievementImpact
DemocratizationMade common people and nature fit subjects for poetry
Language ReformBroke "poetic diction" convention; natural language
Emotion-CenteredShifted focus from form/rules to feeling/emotion
Nature EmphasisNature as moral teacher and source of inspiration
RememberWORDSWORTH = Spontaneous Overflow + Emotion Recollected + Real Language of Men + Man Speaking to Men

SAMUEL TAYLOR COLERIDGE (1772-1834)

Biographia Literaria (1817)

AspectDetails
Full TitleBiographia Literaria; or Biographical Sketches of My Literary Life and Opinions
Structure24 chapters; mixture of autobiography, philosophy, literary criticism
Chapters XIII-XIV most important for theory
Chapters XVII-XXII on Wordsworth
SignificanceMost philosophical Romantic critical work
Reconciles German philosophy (Kant, Schelling) with English criticism
MCQ AlertBiographia Literaria (1817) = Coleridge's major critical work, 24 chapters

Imagination vs. Fancy (Chapter XIII)

ConceptDefinition
Primary Imagination"The living Power and prime Agent of all human Perception"
• Universal human faculty
• Creates perception itself
• Repetition in finite mind of eternal act of creation
• How we perceive reality
• Involuntary, unconscious
Secondary Imagination"Echo" of Primary Imagination
Poetic/creative faculty
• Co-exists with conscious will
Dissolves, diffuses, dissipates to recreate
• Struggles to idealize and unify
SYNTHETIC: Fuses disparate elements into organic unity
• Creates new wholes from parts
• Voluntary, artistic
FancyNOT creative, merely ASSOCIATIVE
• Mode of Memory
"No other counters to play with but fixities and definites"
• Aggregative, NOT fusional
• Brings together images without real unity
• Mechanical combination
• Like beads on string (juxtaposed, not fused)
Examples: Simile, allegory (A + B remain separate)
Critical DistinctionIMAGINATION = synthetic, creative, unifying (highest)
FANCY = associative, mechanical, aggregative (lower)

Imagination: Esemplastic Power

TermMeaning
EsemplasticColeridge coined term from Greek: "to shape into one"
"The power of reducing multitude into unity of effect"
Imagination FUSES elements into organic whole
Example: Metaphor (A becomes B; true fusion)
Organic UnityTrue poetry creates living, organic whole
Parts interdependent (like organism)
NOT mechanical assembly

Criticism of Wordsworth (Chapters XVII-XXII)

PraiseCriticism
Merits• Purity of language
• Perfect truth to nature
• Meditative pathos
• Imaginative power
• Original gift of spreading atmosphere
• Depth of feeling
DefectsInconstancy of style: Mingles profound with trivial
Matter-of-factness: Sometimes too prosaic
Theory of poetic diction WRONG: Language of poetry MUST differ from prose
Undue predilection for dramatic form in lyric
• Occasional prolixity (wordiness)
Poetic Diction DebateWordsworth says: No difference between language of prose and poetry
Coleridge says: Poetry REQUIRES different language - selection, order, arrangement matter
Poetry = "best words in best order"
Meter implies heightened language
Famous QuoteColeridge: "Prose = words in their best order; Poetry = the best words in the best order"

Shakespeare Criticism

ConceptColeridge's View
Organic FormShakespeare's plays have organic form (NOT mechanical)
Form grows from within, inseparable from content
Challenges neoclassical criticism (rules, unities)
Judgment = GeniusContra earlier critics who said Shakespeare = natural genius without art
"No work of genius dares want its appropriate form"
Shakespeare possessed judgment EQUAL to genius
Perfect balance: Imagination + Judgment
MethodPsychological criticism - analyzes characters' inner states
Character analysis as key to plays
HamletExcessive thought, deficient action
"Great, enormous intellectual activity, and a consequent proportionate aversion to real action"
Balance of reflection and deed destroyed

Poetry vs. Poem (Chapter XIV)

DistinctionExplanation
PoemMetrical composition with parts mutually supporting each other
Whole designed to afford pleasure
Technical criterion
PoetryImaginative quality; can exist in prose
Qualitative criterion
"Poetry of the highest kind may exist without meter"
Perfect PoemCombines both: Metrical composition + Imaginative quality
"Proposes to itself such delight from the whole as is compatible with a distinct gratification from each component part"

Willing Suspension of Disbelief

ConceptExplanation
Famous Phrase"Willing suspension of disbelief for the moment, which constitutes poetic faith"
ContextExplaining his role vs. Wordsworth's in Lyrical Ballads:
Coleridge: Supernatural subjects made believable (Ancient Mariner)
Wordsworth: Everyday subjects made interesting
MeaningReader temporarily accepts fictional world's premises
NOT belief, but suspension of skepticism
Active cooperation between poet and reader
MCQ Hotspot"Willing suspension of disbelief" = Coleridge's phrase for poetic faith

Coleridge's Significance

AchievementImpact
Philosophical DepthMost philosophically rigorous Romantic critic
Imagination TheorySophisticated analysis of creative process
Organic UnityInfluential concept in formalist criticism
Shakespeare DefenseChampioned Shakespeare's artistic judgment
RememberCOLERIDGE = Primary/Secondary Imagination vs. Fancy + Esemplastic Power + Willing Suspension of Disbelief + Organic Form

PERCY BYSSHE SHELLEY (1792-1822)

A Defence of Poetry (1821, published 1840)

AspectDetails
OccasionResponse to Thomas Love Peacock's The Four Ages of Poetry (1820)
Peacock argued: Poetry in decline, inferior to science/reason in modern age
PublicationWritten 1821; published posthumously 1840 by Mary Shelley
FormEssay; passionate, eloquent defense of poetry's value
ToneMost idealistic, exalted Romantic vision of poetry
MCQ AlertShelley's Defence (1821/1840) responds to Peacock's Four Ages of Poetry

Shelley's Theory of Poetry

ConceptDetails
Imagination vs. ReasonReason: Analytical, divides, enumerates (to logizein - "to reason")
Imagination: Synthetic, perceives relations, unifies (to poiein - "to make")
Poetry = product of Imagination
Reason = instrument; Imagination = agent
Poetry's Essence"Poetry is the expression of the Imagination"
NOT meter (though often uses it)
NOT rhyme or specific form
Essence = imaginative expression of eternal truths
Broad DefinitionPoetry includes:
• Plato's dialogues
• Herodotus's history
• Certain philosophical/scientific works
ANY work expressing imaginative vision

Poet as Legislator

Famous ClaimExplanation
"Unacknowledged Legislators""Poets are the unacknowledged legislators of the world" (closing line)
Meaning:
• Poets shape values, morality, culture
• Create vision that society gradually adopts
• Influence deeper than explicit laws
• "Unacknowledged" = work indirectly, not recognized as lawmakers
Prophetic Role"Poets are the hierophants of an unapprehended inspiration"
"Mirrors of the gigantic shadows which futurity casts upon the present"
Poets intuit future, reveal hidden truths
Most Famous Line"Poets are the unacknowledged legislators of the world"

Moral Effect of Poetry

ArgumentDetails
Enlarges Sympathy"The great secret of morals is love"
Poetry cultivates sympathetic imagination
Going out of our own nature, identifying with others
Moral imagination: Ability to see from others' perspectives
Against DidacticismPoetry teaches NOT through direct precepts
Teaches by awakening moral sensibility
"Ethical science arranges... poetry acts"
Experiential, not prescriptive
Pleasure & MoralityPleasure from poetry refines feelings
NOT opposed to morality - foundation of it
Pleasure = expansion of being, sympathetic joy

Poetry vs. Utility

DefenseArgument
Against PeacockPeacock: Science/reason more useful than poetry in modern age
Shelley: Poetry MORE necessary as civilization advances
"We have more moral, political and historical wisdom than we know how to reduce into practice"
Need poetry to cultivate sympathetic imagination
Poetry's UtilityCreates values that make civilization possible
Without poetry: "Man... would be selfish and narrow"
Material progress without poetry = dangerous imbalance
"Poetry ever communicates all the pleasure which men are capable of receiving"
Golden AgePoetry creates "beautiful idealisms of moral excellence"
Inspires improvement of society
Prophetic vision of better world

Inspiration and Creation

ConceptDetails
Divine Inspiration"A man cannot say, 'I will compose poetry'"
Poetic inspiration comes unbidden
"Mind in creation is as a fading coal"
Moment of inspiration = spontaneous, involuntary
Fading Coal Metaphor"Mind in creation is as a fading coal, which some invisible influence, like an inconstant wind, awakens to transitory brightness"
Inspiration fleeting, beyond conscious control
Poet catches inspiration while it lasts
CompositionOriginal conception best
Revision often weakens initial inspiration
Most glorious poetry = product of inspired moments

Shelley's Significance

AchievementImpact
Highest ClaimsMost exalted view of poet's role in Romantic period
Moral ImaginationPoetry as cultivating sympathy and ethical sensibility
Against UtilitarianismDefense of poetry against scientific materialism
Prophetic VisionPoet as seer, cultural leader
RememberSHELLEY = Unacknowledged Legislators + Fading Coal + Moral Imagination + Imagination > Reason

OTHER ROMANTIC CRITICS

JOHN KEATS (1795-1821) - Letters

ConceptDetails (from Letters)
Negative Capability"When a man is capable of being in uncertainties, mysteries, doubts, without any irritable reaching after fact and reason"
Letter to George and Tom Keats (Dec 21, 1817)
Ability to remain in uncertainty
Accept mystery without forcing rational explanation
Shakespeare exemplified this (vs. Coleridge who couldn't resist philosophy)
Camelion Poet"Camelion [Chameleon] Poet" - NO fixed identity
"Has no self... continually... filling some other body"
Empathetic identification with subjects
Self-effacing, impersonal creation
Beauty & Truth"Beauty is truth, truth beauty" - Ode on a Grecian Urn
Aesthetic and philosophical unity
Poetry reveals truth through beauty
Famous Phrase"Negative Capability" - Keats's term for accepting uncertainty

WILLIAM HAZLITT (1778-1830)

WorkContribution
Lectures on English Poets (1818)Criticism of major English poets
Defense of poetry's imaginative power
Characters of Shakespeare's Plays (1817)Character analysis approach
Psychological insights into dramatic figures
The Spirit of the Age (1825)Essays on contemporary writers
Cultural criticism
StyleImpressionistic, personal response
Quotable, aphoristic prose
Sympathetic imagination in criticism

THOMAS DE QUINCEY (1785-1859)

ConceptDetails
Literature of Power vs. KnowledgeLiterature of Knowledge: Teaches, informs (science, philosophy)
• Function = instruct
• Appeals to understanding
• Transitory value (superseded by new knowledge)
Literature of Power: Moves, affects (poetry, great imaginative prose)
• Function = move, elevate feelings
• Appeals to emotions
• Permanent value (not superseded)
Poetry = Literature of Power
DistinctionKnowledge = teaches; Power = moves (De Quincey)

ROMANTIC CRITICISM - KEY THEMES

ThemeRomantic PositionContrast with Neoclassical
ImaginationSupreme creative faculty
Unifying, synthesizing power
Neoclassical: Reason, judgment primary
EmotionSource and subject of poetry
"Spontaneous overflow"
Neoclassical: Restraint, decorum
NatureSource of inspiration, moral teacher
Healing, spiritual force
Neoclassical: Art/civilization over nature
OriginalityCreate from within, unique vision
Individual expression valued
Neoclassical: Imitation of models
Universal truths
LanguageNatural, "real language of men"
Against artificial poetic diction
Neoclassical: Elevated, polished style
Generic poetic language
RulesFreedom, organic form
Rules secondary to vision
Neoclassical: Follow classical rules
Unities, decorum
PoetInspired seer, prophet
"Man speaking to men" OR "legislator"
Neoclassical: Skilled craftsman
Teacher through delight
ChildhoodPure, intuitive, innocent
Close to nature
Neoclassical: Immature stage
Adulthood superior

MCQ RAPID FIRE - Romantic Criticism

Question TypeAnswer
Manifesto of English RomanticismWordsworth's Preface to Lyrical Ballads (1800/1802)
Wordsworth's famous definition"Spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings" + "emotion recollected in tranquillity"
Wordsworth on poet"A man speaking to men"
Wordsworth's language theory"Real language of men" - reject poetic diction
Coleridge's major workBiographia Literaria (1817), 24 chapters
Primary Imagination"Living Power and prime Agent of all human Perception" - universal faculty
Secondary ImaginationPoetic/creative faculty; "dissolves, diffuses, dissipates to recreate"
FancyAssociative, mechanical; "no other counters... but fixities and definites"
EsemplasticColeridge's term: "to shape into one" - imagination's unifying power
"Willing suspension of disbelief"Coleridge - reader's acceptance of fiction (poetic faith)
Organic formColeridge - form grows from within (vs. mechanical form)
"Best words in best order"Coleridge - definition of poetry (vs. prose = "words in best order")
Shelley's Defence responds toPeacock's The Four Ages of Poetry (1820)
"Unacknowledged legislators"Shelley - "Poets are the unacknowledged legislators of the world"
"Fading coal"Shelley - "Mind in creation is as a fading coal" (inspiration fleeting)
Shelley on moral effectPoetry enlarges sympathy, cultivates moral imagination
Keats's "Negative Capability""Being in uncertainties, mysteries, doubts" without forcing reason
Keats's Camelion PoetPoet has no fixed self; empathetically identifies with subjects
De Quincey's distinctionLiterature of Knowledge (teaches) vs. Literature of Power (moves)
Romantic core valuesImagination + Emotion + Nature + Originality + Freedom