FEMINIST CRITICISM

Syllabus Coverage: Paper 02 - Part C: Critical Theory - Topic 28
Period: First Wave (1792-1920s), Second Wave (1960s-1980s), Third Wave (1990s-present)
Key Figures: Wollstonecraft, Woolf, Beauvoir, Friedan, Millett, Showalter, Gilbert & Gubar, Cixous, Irigaray, Butler, hooks
Core Concerns: Gender inequality, patriarchy, representation of women, recovering women's voices

WHAT IS FEMINIST CRITICISM?

Aspect Details
Definition Literary criticism examining gender inequality and patriarchal assumptions
• How women represented in literature?
• How gender shapes reading, writing, canon formation?
• Recovery of women writers
• Challenge male-dominated literary tradition
Two Main Approaches 1. Images of Women: Critique misrepresentation in male-authored texts
2. Gynocriticism: Study women writers, women's literary tradition (Elaine Showalter)
Both important but different focuses
Three Waves of Feminism First Wave (late 18th-early 20th c.): Legal rights, suffrage, education
Second Wave (1960s-80s): Workplace, sexuality, reproductive rights, literary criticism
Third Wave (1990s-present): Diversity, intersectionality, queer theory, transnational
Literary feminist criticism = mainly Second/Third Wave

FIRST WAVE PRECURSORS

MARY WOLLSTONECRAFT (1759-1797)

Concept Details
A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792) Founding feminist text
Women NOT naturally inferior - denied education makes them appear so
• Argues for women's education, reason, autonomy
"I do not wish women to have power over men, but over themselves"
• Response to Rousseau (who excluded women from education)

VIRGINIA WOOLF (1882-1941)

Concept Details
A Room of One's Own (1929) ESSENTIAL feminist literary criticism text
• Extended essay based on Cambridge lectures
"A woman must have money and a room of her own if she is to write fiction"
• Material conditions (economic independence, private space) necessary for women's writing
Shakespeare's Sister Thought experiment: What if Shakespeare had equally talented sister?
• "Judith Shakespeare" would have NO opportunities
• Denied education, forced to marry, mocked for ambition
"Any woman born with great talent in 16th c. would have gone mad, shot herself..."
• Demonstrates systemic barriers, not lack of talent
Androgyny "It is fatal for anyone who writes to think of their sex"
• Great mind is androgynous (Coleridge's idea)
• Male/female elements balanced
Controversial: later feminists reject this (gender DOES matter)
Women and Fiction • Women's literary tradition emerging (Austen, Brontës, Eliot)
• Need to create "a woman's sentence" - not just imitate male forms
• Recover lost women writers
• Canon needs expansion

SECOND WAVE FEMINIST CRITICISM (1960s-1980s)

SIMONE DE BEAUVOIR (1908-1986)

Concept Details
The Second Sex (1949) FOUNDATIONAL Second Wave feminist text
• Published 1949 (France), translated 1953
• Philosophical, existentialist analysis of women's oppression
Influenced ALL later feminist thought
Famous Quote "One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman"
Gender = social construction, NOT biological essence
• "Femininity" is taught, performed, imposed
• Revolutionary idea: sex (biological) ≠ gender (cultural)
• Foundation for later gender theory (Butler)
Woman as Other Man = Subject, Self, Absolute; Woman = Other, Object, Inessential
• Man defines himself; Woman defined by relation to Man
Woman = "the second sex" - derivative, inferior
• Draws on Hegelian dialectic, Sartre's existentialism
Immanence vs. Transcendence Men = Transcendence (freedom, project, create)
Women = Immanence (trapped in body, domesticity, repetition)
• Women denied transcendence by patriarchy
• Must achieve economic independence, reject marriage/motherhood as sole identity

KATE MILLETT (1934-2017)

Concept Details
Sexual Politics (1970) "Politics" extends to personal/sexual realm
"The personal is political" (second wave slogan)
• PhD thesis turned bestseller
• Analyzed sexism in D.H. Lawrence, Henry Miller, Norman Mailer
Patriarchy Systematic male domination in all spheres
• Political institution, not just individual prejudice
• Operates through family, education, religion, literature
• Literature reproduces/reinforces patriarchal ideology

ELAINE SHOWALTER (b. 1941)

Concept Details
A Literature of Their Own (1977) History of women novelists in Britain (1800s-1970s)
• Recovery project: establish women's literary tradition
Not marginal additions to male tradition, but THEIR OWN tradition
Gynocriticism Showalter's term (1979) - study of women writers
"The female as producer of textual meaning"
• Focus on women's writing, NOT just images in male texts
• Women's literary history, themes, forms, language
Shift from critique of male writers to celebration of female writers
Three Phases of Women's Writing 1. Feminine (1840-1880): Imitation of male tradition (Brontës)
2. Feminist (1880-1920): Protest, advocacy (Schreiner, Grand)
3. Female (1920-onward): Self-discovery, autonomy (Woolf, Lessing)
Progression from imitation → protest → independence

SANDRA GILBERT & SUSAN GUBAR

Concept Details
The Madwoman in the Attic (1979) Feminist reading of 19th-century women writers
• Title from Jane Eyre (Bertha Mason in attic)
HUGELY influential study
Anxiety of Authorship Women writers face "anxiety of authorship" (not Bloom's "anxiety of influence")
• Male tradition denies women authority to create
"The pen is a metaphorical penis" (male literary power)
• Women struggle for legitimacy as writers
• Literary history = male genealogy (fathers/sons)
Madwoman as Double Mad/bad female character = author's rebellious double
• Example: Bertha Mason (Jane Eyre's rage/rebellion)
• Proper heroine = socially acceptable
• Madwoman = repressed fury, desire for freedom
Women writers encode resistance through these doubles
Palimpsest Women's texts contain hidden story beneath surface
• Surface: conformity to patriarchal norms
• Beneath: subversive, rebellious meaning
• "Covers story" technique

FRENCH FEMINISM - Écriture Féminine

HÉLÈNE CIXOUS (b. 1937)

Concept Details
"The Laugh of the Medusa" (1975) MAJOR French feminist essay
• Call for women to write from their bodies, experience
"Woman must write her self" - "écriture féminine"
Écriture Féminine "Feminine writing" - writing the body
Fluid, multiple, non-linear, jouissant (blissful)
• Opposes phallogocentric (male/reason/logic) discourse
• Women's writing = disruptive, subversive of patriarchal language
• NOT just by women, but embodying "feminine" principles
"Write Your Self" • Women silenced for centuries
"Woman must put herself into the text - as into the world and into history - by her own movement"
• Reclaim voice, body, sexuality
Medusa Medusa not monstrous but laughing, beautiful
• Male mythology: Medusa = castrating threat
• Cixous: Medusa = powerful, joyful woman
• Reclaim demonized feminine

LUCE IRIGARAY (b. 1930)

Concept Details
Critique of Phallocentrism Western thought centered on masculine/phallic
• Psychoanalysis (Freud, Lacan) = male-centered
• Woman defined as "lack" (no penis)
Irigaray: Need specifically FEMININE symbolic order
"This Sex Which Is Not One" (1977) • Title = pun: woman's sex "not one" (multiple, plural)
• Female sexuality NOT inferior/lacking but DIFFERENT
Two lips (multiplicity) vs. one phallus (singularity)
• Essentialism debate

THIRD WAVE & CONTEMPORARY FEMINISM

JUDITH BUTLER (b. 1956)

Concept Details
Gender Trouble (1990) REVOLUTIONARY gender theory text
• Founded queer theory
Challenged feminist assumption of stable "woman" category
Gender Performativity "Gender is performance, not essence"
No pre-existing gender identity - gender CREATED through repeated performance
• Acts, gestures, speech PRODUCE gender (not express it)
"Gender is the repeated stylization of the body"
• No "natural" or "original" gender - all is performance/construction
Compulsory Heterosexuality Heterosexuality enforced as norm (Adrienne Rich's term, Butler develops)
• Gender = effect of compulsory heterosexuality
• "Coherent" gender (man=masculine, woman=feminine) = regulatory fiction
• Drag reveals performativity (imitates no original)
Sex vs. Gender Collapse Even biological "sex" is culturally constructed
• Not just gender (cultural) but SEX (biological) is discursive
Sex/gender distinction collapses - both constructed
• Radical challenge to earlier feminism
Impact • Enabled transgender studies
• Queer theory
• Challenged essentialist feminism
• Controversial within feminism

BELL HOOKS (1952-2021)

Concept Details
Intersectionality Gender intersects with race, class, sexuality
Can't analyze gender in isolation from race/class
• White middle-class feminism ≠ universal women's experience
• Black women face BOTH racism AND sexism
• Term coined by Kimberlé Crenshaw (1989), hooks elaborated
Feminist Theory (1984) • Critique of white bourgeois feminism
• Feminism must address racism, classism
• Accessible writing style (not academic jargon)
lowercase name • "bell hooks" (not capitalized) = pen name
• Focuses attention on IDEAS, not individual ego

COMPARATIVE TABLE - FEMINIST APPROACHES

Approach Key Figures Focus Method
Images of Women Millett, Fetterley How women represented in male texts Critique stereotypes, misogyny
Gynocriticism Showalter, Gilbert & Gubar Women writers, women's tradition Recovery, canon revision
French Feminism Cixous, Irigaray, Kristeva Language, body, feminine writing Écriture féminine, psychoanalysis
Materialist Feminism Marxist feminists Economic/class factors Base/superstructure, labor
Gender Theory / Queer Butler Gender as performance, construction Deconstruction, performativity
Intersectional hooks, Crenshaw, Lorde Race, class, gender intersection Multiple oppressions, coalitions

MCQ RAPID FIRE

Question Type Key Facts
Wollstonecraft Vindication of Rights of Woman (1792) - education, reason
Woolf's Famous Line "A woman must have money and a room of her own" (1929)
Beauvoir's Famous Line "One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman" (1949)
Showalter's Term Gynocriticism (1979) - study of women as writers
Showalter's Three Phases Feminine (imitation) → Feminist (protest) → Female (independence)
Gilbert & Gubar Madwoman in the Attic (1979) - anxiety of authorship, doubles
Cixous Essay "The Laugh of the Medusa" (1975) - écriture féminine
Butler's Book Gender Trouble (1990) - gender performativity
Butler's Key Idea Gender = performance, not essence; "repeated stylization"
Intersectionality Crenshaw (term, 1989), hooks, Lorde - race + gender + class
Second Wave Slogan "The personal is political" (Millett)

COMMON CONFUSIONS

Don't Confuse Distinction
Sex vs. Gender (Traditional) Sex = biological; Gender = cultural construction (Beauvoir)
Butler: BOTH are constructed
Gynocriticism vs. Images of Women Gynocriticism = study women writers; Images = critique male representations
Anglo-American vs. French Feminism Anglo-American = practical, historical, recovery; French = theoretical, psychoanalytic, language
Second vs. Third Wave Second = universal "woman"; Third = diversity, intersectionality, queer
Beauvoir vs. Butler Beauvoir: "becomes a woman" (socialization); Butler: gender = performance (no essence at all)
Showalter's Phases Feminine/Feminist/Female (NOT First/Second/Third Wave!)
Study Strategy: Master KEY QUOTES: Woolf ("room of one's own"), Beauvoir ("not born, but becomes"), Butler ("repeated stylization"). Know DATES: Wollstonecraft 1792, Woolf 1929, Beauvoir 1949, Millett 1970, Showalter 1977, Gilbert & Gubar 1979, Butler 1990. Understand GYNOCRITICISM (Showalter) vs. écriture féminine (Cixous) vs. performativity (Butler). Know Showalter's THREE PHASES of women's writing. Understand INTERSECTIONALITY (hooks, Crenshaw).

Feminist Criticism Complete
Woolf | Beauvoir | Showalter | Gilbert & Gubar | Cixous | Butler | hooks