PSYCHOANALYTICAL CRITICISM

Syllabus Coverage: Paper 02 - Part C: Critical Theory - Topic 29
Period: 1900s-present (Freud 1900s, Lacan 1950s-70s)
Key Figures: Sigmund Freud, Carl Jung, Jacques Lacan, Harold Bloom
Core Method: Applying psychoanalytic concepts (unconscious, repression, Oedipus, etc.) to literary texts, authors, characters, readers

WHAT IS PSYCHOANALYTIC CRITICISM?

Aspect Details
Definition Literary criticism using psychoanalytic theory
• Analyzes unconscious motivations in texts, characters, authors
Three main approaches:
1. Psychoanalyze AUTHOR (biographical)
2. Psychoanalyze CHARACTERS (as if real people)
3. Psychoanalyze TEXT ITSELF (symptomatic reading)
Foundational Assumption Literature = expression of unconscious
• Like dreams, slips, symptoms - reveals hidden desires, conflicts
• Author may not be aware of deeper meanings
Text = symptom of psychic processes
Origins Freud himself applied psychoanalysis to literature
• Analyzed Hamlet, Oedipus, Dostoevsky, Leonardo da Vinci
• Literary critics then adapted psychoanalysis systematically

SIGMUND FREUD (1856-1939)

FREUD'S KEY CONCEPTS

Concept Details
The Unconscious Most of mind is UNCONSCIOUS
Conscious = tip of iceberg; Unconscious = vast hidden depths
• Contains repressed desires, traumatic memories, forbidden wishes
• Influences behavior without awareness
The Interpretation of Dreams (1900) - foundational text
Id, Ego, Superego Structural model of psyche (later Freud):
Id: Primitive, instinctual, pleasure principle, unconscious (wants NOW)
Ego: Rational, mediates id/reality, reality principle, conscious/unconscious (negotiates)
Superego: Moral conscience, internalized parental/social rules, largely unconscious (judges)
Psyche = battlefield of conflicting forces
Repression Pushing unacceptable desires into unconscious
• Primary defense mechanism
• Repressed content RETURNS in disguised forms (dreams, symptoms, slips, literature)
"The return of the repressed"
Oedipus Complex Universal childhood psychosexual crisis
Boy desires mother, wants to kill father (rival)
• Fear of castration → repression of desires → identification with father
• Foundation of later psychology, morality, culture
Named after Sophocles' Oedipus Rex
• Female version: Electra Complex (Jung's term, Freud resisted)
Dream-Work Unconscious transforms latent content into manifest content
Manifest content: Dream as remembered
Latent content: Hidden unconscious wishes
Dream-work mechanisms:
  - Condensation (multiple ideas compressed)
  - Displacement (importance shifted to trivial detail)
  - Symbolization (abstract represented concretely)
  - Secondary revision (narrative coherence imposed)
Literature works like dreams - disguises unconscious content
Pleasure Principle vs. Reality Principle Pleasure principle: Seek pleasure, avoid pain (id)
Reality principle: Defer gratification, accept reality (ego)
• Civilization = suppression of pleasure principle

FREUD'S LITERARY CRITICISM

Work/Analysis Key Points
"Creative Writers and Day-Dreaming" (1908) Literary creation = adult's daydream
• Writer transforms private fantasy into universal form
• Readers vicariously satisfy repressed wishes
Literature = wish-fulfillment (like dreams)
Hamlet Analysis Hamlet's delay = Oedipal guilt
• Can't kill Claudius because Claudius did what Hamlet unconsciously wanted (kill father, marry mother)
Hamlet sees his own repressed desires enacted
• Ernest Jones elaborated in Hamlet and Oedipus (1949)
"The 'Uncanny'" (1919) Das Unheimliche - familiar made strange
Uncanny = return of repressed (primitive beliefs, infantile complexes)
• Example: Doubles, severed limbs, automata, repetition
• Gothic literature exploits uncanny
• Analyzed Hoffmann's "The Sandman"
"Dostoevsky and Parricide" (1928) • Dostoevsky's patricidal wishes, epilepsy
Brothers Karamazov = working through father-complex

CARL GUSTAV JUNG (1875-1961)

Concept Details
Collective Unconscious BEYOND personal unconscious = shared, universal unconscious
Inherited psychic structures common to all humanity
• Contains ARCHETYPES
Explains why same symbols/myths appear across cultures
• Break with Freud: NOT just repressed personal content
Archetypes Universal, primordial images/patterns in collective unconscious
Examples:
  - The Hero: Quest, trials, transformation
  - The Shadow: Dark, repressed aspects of self
  - The Anima/Animus: Feminine in male (anima), masculine in female (animus)
  - The Great Mother: Nurturing/devouring feminine
  - The Wise Old Man: Guide, mentor
  - The Trickster: Mischief, boundary-crossing
Literature draws on archetypes → universal resonance
Literary Application Archetypal criticism: Identify recurring patterns, myths
• Northrop Frye (influenced by Jung) - Anatomy of Criticism (1957)
• Joseph Campbell - The Hero with a Thousand Faces (1949)
• Less emphasis on author's neurosis, more on universal patterns
Individuation Psychological maturation - integrating conscious/unconscious, shadow, anima/animus
• Hero's journey = individuation process
Quest narratives = symbolic individuation

JACQUES LACAN (1901-1981)

"The Insistence of the Letter in the Unconscious" (1957) & Other Works

Concept Details
Lacan's Importance "Return to Freud" via structuralism/post-structuralism
French psychoanalyst, hugely influential on literary theory
• Notoriously difficult, obscure style
• Influenced Althusser, Žižek, feminists (Irigaray, Kristeva), film theory
"The Unconscious is Structured Like a Language" MOST FAMOUS Lacanian dictum
Unconscious operates through linguistic structures (metaphor, metonymy)
• Freud's condensation = METAPHOR (paradigmatic)
• Freud's displacement = METONYMY (syntagmatic)
Brings together Freud + Saussure
• Unconscious = signifying chain, not biological instincts
The Three Orders Imaginary, Symbolic, Real:
The Imaginary: Realm of images, mirror stage, illusory wholeness
The Symbolic: Realm of language, law, Father, culture
The Real: That which resists symbolization, traumatic, impossible to represent
Subject constituted through these three orders
Mirror Stage 6-18 months: infant sees self in mirror, identifies with image
Moment of MISRECOGNITION (méconnaissance)
• Image appears unified, but infant is fragmented
• Foundation of ego = alienation
• "I" = Other's image, not autonomous self
• Imaginary identification
Name-of-the-Father Entry into Symbolic order
• Paternal law, language, prohibition of incest
• Oedipal moment: acceptance of symbolic castration
• Subject becomes "I" within language
Desire permanently split, always mediated by signifiers
Objet Petit a "Object-cause of desire" - always lacking, unattainable
• NOT object we desire, but what CAUSES desire
• Gap, lack around which desire circulates
• Desire = endless chain (no final satisfaction)
Literary Application • Texts = signifying chains, desire structures
• Focus on LANGUAGE, not author's biography
• Gaps, silences, contradictions = the Real breaking through
• Subject-positions constructed by text

HAROLD BLOOM (1930-2019)

The Anxiety of Influence (1973)

Concept Details
Anxiety of Influence Poets struggle with "burden of the past"
Strong poet feels "belatedness" - precursors already said everything
• Oedipal relation: poet = son, precursor = father
• Must "slay" father to create own space
Influence = anxiety, not inspiration
Misprision "Creative misreading" of precursor
• Strong poet MISreads predecessor (willfully, creatively)
• NOT passive reception but active distortion
• Example: Milton misreads Spenser; Wordsworth misreads Milton
Six Revisionary Ratios Mechanisms poets use to distance from precursor:
1. Clinamen: Swerve, corrective movement
2. Tessera: Completion, filling in precursor's gaps
3. Kenosis: Emptying out, discontinuity
4. Daemonization: Counter-sublime
5. Askesis: Self-purgation, isolating self
6. Apophrades: Return of dead, precursor in poet's own voice
Don't memorize all 6 for MCQ - know general concept!
Canon & Western Tradition • Bloom: Canon = aesthetic greatness (NOT politics)
The Western Canon (1994) - defends traditional canon
• Controversial: accused of elitism, conservatism

APPLICATIONS OF PSYCHOANALYTIC CRITICISM

Approach Examples & Methods
Analyzing Characters • Treat as "real" people with unconscious
• Hamlet's Oedipal conflict
• Lady Macbeth's repressed guilt
Problem: Characters are TEXTUAL constructs, not people
Analyzing Authors • Author's biography → text
• Example: Poe's tales = working through mother's death, alcoholism
Problem: Biographical fallacy (related to Intentional Fallacy)
Analyzing TEXT as Symptom MOST SOPHISTICATED approach (Lacanian)
• Text itself = symptomatic structure
• Analyze linguistic operations, gaps, contradictions
• What does text repress? What returns?
• NOT author's psyche, but TEXT'S unconscious
Analyzing READER • Reader-response + psychoanalysis
• Norman Holland: Reading = transference
• How reader projects, identifies, defends

COMPARATIVE TABLE - PSYCHOANALYTIC APPROACHES

Theorist Key Concept Literary Focus
Freud Unconscious, Oedipus, repression, dream-work Author's neurosis, character motivations, wish-fulfillment
Jung Collective unconscious, archetypes Universal patterns, myths, hero's journey
Lacan "Unconscious structured like language," Mirror Stage, Name-of-the-Father Textual signification, desire structures, subject-positions
Bloom Anxiety of influence, misprision Poet's struggle with precursors, Oedipal literary history

MCQ RAPID FIRE

Question Type Key Facts
Freud's Foundational Text The Interpretation of Dreams (1900)
Id/Ego/Superego Id = pleasure (wants); Ego = reality (negotiates); Superego = morality (judges)
Oedipus Complex Boy desires mother, wants kill father; Castration anxiety; Repression
Dream-Work Condensation, Displacement, Symbolization, Secondary Revision
Freud's "Uncanny" Return of repressed; Familiar made strange; 1919 essay
Jung vs. Freud Jung = COLLECTIVE unconscious (universal archetypes); Freud = personal unconscious
Archetypes Examples Hero, Shadow, Anima/Animus, Great Mother, Wise Old Man, Trickster
Lacan's Famous Dictum "The unconscious is structured like a language"
Lacan's Three Orders Imaginary, Symbolic, Real
Mirror Stage 6-18 months; Misrecognition; Alienation; Imaginary identification
Bloom's Book The Anxiety of Influence (1973) - Oedipal poetic struggle
Bloom's Term Misprision = creative misreading of precursor

COMMON CONFUSIONS

Don't Confuse Distinction
Id vs. Ego vs. Superego Id = instinct; Ego = mediator; Superego = conscience (NOT ego = self in general sense)
Manifest vs. Latent Content Manifest = dream as remembered; Latent = hidden unconscious wish
Freud vs. Jung Unconscious Freud = personal (repressed); Jung = personal + COLLECTIVE (inherited archetypes)
Condensation vs. Displacement Condensation = compression (metaphor); Displacement = shift (metonymy)
Lacan's Imaginary vs. Symbolic Imaginary = images, mirror, illusion; Symbolic = language, law, Name-of-Father
Anxiety of Influence vs. Anxiety of Authorship Influence = Bloom (poet vs. precursor); Authorship = Gilbert & Gubar (women writers vs. male tradition)
Oedipus Complex vs. Electra Complex Oedipus = boy (Freud); Electra = girl (Jung's term, Freud didn't use)
Study Strategy: Master FREUD'S BASICS: Unconscious, Id/Ego/Superego, Oedipus Complex, dream-work (condensation/displacement), repression, "Uncanny" (1919). Know JUNG'S BREAK: Collective unconscious, archetypes (Hero, Shadow, Anima/Animus). Understand LACAN: "Unconscious structured like language," Three Orders (Imaginary/Symbolic/Real), Mirror Stage. Know BLOOM: Anxiety of Influence (1973), misprision, Oedipal poetic struggle. Be able to COMPARE approaches.

Psychoanalytical Criticism Complete
Freud | Jung | Lacan | Bloom